--- title: "Australia's Digital Duty of Care. When Interpretation Becomes the Harm." date: 2026-11-21 author: "Erwin Groen" image: /media/digital-duty-of-care-australia.png description: "Australia's proposed Digital Duty of Care raises a difficult question: who decides what is harmful, and what happens when that interpretation is wrong? An Own The Dot perspective on online safety, digital identity and Handshake." tags: - Australia - Digital Duty of Care - Online Safety - Handshake - Internet Naming - Digital Independence --- Australia wants to lead the world in online safety. I understand why. Children should be protected from exploitation, people should have meaningful ways to address serious abuse. Digital platforms should not be free to ignore risks created by the services they operate. But as Australia's proposed Digital Duty of Care moves closer to a Senate decision, I find myself disappointed by something at the centre of the debate: **who gets to decide what is harmful, and what happens when that interpretation is wrong?** An interpretation that is intended to prevent harm can, in some circumstances, become a source of harm itself. ## A bill moving closer to a decision On 20 November 2026, a Senate committee recommended that the *Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026* proceed, subject to consideration of its recommendations. Those recommendations reportedly include a possible civil right of action for people harmed by breaches of the duty, and clearer treatment of low risk websites, such as small businesses and educational or religious services. The recommendations are not yet law. They do not mean the Senate has passed the bill. Under the government's proposal, online services would have duties to take reasonable steps to protect users from serious harm. The proposed framework also includes measures for user choice and stronger enforcement by the eSafety Commissioner. There is a legitimate purpose here. Preventing serious harm is better than waiting until after it happens. Yet the way a law is applied matters as much as the intention behind it. ## When interpretation becomes the harm What one person considers offensive, another might regard as legitimate criticism, political disagreement or a deeply held belief. Not all offensive speech is unlawful, and not every uncomfortable conversation is harmful in the sense that should justify regulatory intervention. That does not excuse threats, exploitation or harassment. It means the distinction must be drawn carefully. My concern is not that a single minister will personally decide the acceptability of every post. That would misrepresent the proposed legislation. The more difficult concern is how broadly expressed obligations might be interpreted by regulators and online services, particularly where the consequences of getting it wrong are substantial. An online service might conclude that removing a lawful but controversial contribution is less risky than allowing it to remain. A person might decide not to express an unpopular view at all. Even where the law contains safeguards, the pressure to avoid enforcement can affect decisions before a regulator ever becomes involved. This is why definitions, proportionality, transparent decision making, independent review and real opportunities to challenge mistakes matter. Without them, a law intended to reduce harm could inadvertently silence lawful discussion or exclude people from services they rely on. ## Leading the world also invites scrutiny Australia describes its online safety reforms as world-leading. If other governments look to Australia's approach, its design and safeguards may influence debates far beyond our borders. That possibility is not proof that any country has adopted this particular legislation. International leadership should be judged by more than the ambition to regulate. It should also be judged by what is preserved: privacy, freedom of expression, due process and the ability to challenge government decisions. A law is not written only for the government that introduces it. Future governments inherit its powers, and their understanding of what constitutes harm may differ. That is precisely why those powers deserve scrutiny now. ## Where Handshake and naming come in Handshake Australia, at [**hns.au**](https://hns.au), exists to raise awareness of Handshake: an independent blockchain-based naming protocol that offers a different way to register and maintain top-level internet names. In the conventional domain name system, a name's registration depends on registrars, registries and the wider ICANN coordinated structure. Handshake records ownership of its top-level names through blockchain rules, rather than through an ordinary central registry's administrative records. That makes a meaningful difference. A properly maintained Handshake name cannot ordinarily be cancelled simply by ordering a conventional central registry to delete its registration. Control is instead tied to cryptographic keys and the protocol's consensus rules. But this is not a promise that a name can never be lost or interfered with. Keys can be compromised. Names require renewal under the protocol. Network rules can change, and legal processes can still affect people and services. Browsers, resolvers, internet providers and hosting companies can also restrict access, regardless of who controls the underlying name. **Owning a name and being able to reach a website are not the same thing.** Nor does independent naming make harmful or unlawful conduct acceptable. Handshake Australia's role is educational: to make Australians aware that another naming model exists, and to explain what it can and cannot do. My personal view, expressed through Own The Dot, is that this choice matters more as governments increase their influence over online services. A person's digital name should not be unnecessarily vulnerable to a single administrative decision, especially where the underlying disagreement concerns an interpretation that may later be challenged or reversed. ## Safety and independence should be able to coexist I do not believe Australians should have to choose between protection from genuine harm and control over their digital identities. A serious online safety framework should protect people, set clear limits on authority and provide effective remedies when decisions are wrong. It should also recognise that the right to hold and maintain an internet name is different from the legality of particular content published through it. My disappointment is that this distinction, and the potential harm caused by inconsistent interpretations, can be too easily lost when regulation is presented primarily as a question of safety. If Australia wants to lead the world, it should lead in protecting people **and** preserving the independence that makes the internet valuable. Because an interpretation can change. The damage caused by acting on it may not be so easily undone. ## Author's note The views expressed in this article are my personal opinions as the author of Own The Dot. They do **not** represent an official position of Handshake Australia ([hns.au](https://hns.au)). Handshake Australia's purpose is to raise awareness of the Handshake naming protocol and independent digital naming. **Erwin Groen** *Own The Dot* ## Sources - [Australian Government — Digital Duty of Care](https://www.infrastructure.gov.au/media-communications/internet/online-safety/digital-duty-care) - [Minister for Communications — Digital Duty of Care next step in Australia's world-leading reforms](https://minister.infrastructure.gov.au/wells/media-release/digital-duty-care-next-step-australias-world-leading-reforms) - [Australian Parliament — Senate inquiry report](https://www.aph.gov.au/Parliamentary_Business/Committees/Senate/Environment_and_Communications/DigitalDutyofCare48P/Report) - [News.com.au — Senate inquiry recommendations, 20 November 2026](https://www.news.com.au/technology/online/social/senate-probe-backs-passing-of-labors-digital-duty-of-care-bill-with-lowrisk-website-exemptions/news-story/236b292ca0d5d6cb76d676c7129516a5) --- **Own the Name | Own the Rules | Own The Dot**